Skip to main content

Is it fun?

This week I ran into the same introspective question that I hit multiple times with Robo-Ninja: Is this game going to be any fun?

It's just really hard to tell, as the developer. I'm way too closely attached to every minute detail to have any idea if this game is remotely fun to play.  I'm pretty sure that's what happened with Deadly Towers.  The only explanation I can come up with is that they didn't get outside input to tell them how bad their game was, and they were too close to see it.  I really don't want to make the next Deadly Towers.


Comments

Bryan R said…
Perhaps it will help to think of the characteristics you've seen in games that were especially fun or especially boring.

It's probably easiest to identify the things that make a game NOT fun. For example, games without enough save points, so you have to replay an easy section over and over to get back to the point where you keep dying. Or, games that increase the difficulty by throwing more and more bad guys at you until your thumbs fall off from mashing the controller. Or, open world games that force you to walk or drive a great distance to get to the next place where something actually happens.

A couple of indie games I've really enjoyed are Braid and Thomas Was Alone. They featured clever concepts which were explored through creative and varied level designs. They were challenging enough to be engaging but not punishing. The solutions involved a mix of strategy and action, but with the emphasis on strategy. Of course, that reflects my preferences. I don't appreciate frenetic action as much as other players might.

None of this will guarantee your game is fun, but it might help point you in the right direction.
Nathan Tolbert said…
Yeah, your thoughts are right on (other than liking Thomas Was Alone. ;-) I got so bored after the first 3 or 4 levels that I never got any further. There just wasn't enough hook other than the clever idea of shapes with personalities.)

I've been spending a decent amount of time playing and thinking about old games that I liked and didn't like, trying to find the elements that made them work or not. The hard part is that sometimes it's really subtle, the things that make or break a game.

The thing I'm most worried about in Atari Anguna is that it will be too boring. There's not a ton of interactive content that I can add to each room, so I'm afraid the world will feel big, boring, and empty. (Of course, now that I've identified that, it's my job to try prevent that, by making the world slightly smaller, making clever dungeon designs that stay interesting, etc).

Bryan R said…
Thomas Was Alone had a real Zen-like quality to me, with its storytime voiceovers and minimalist style. Perhaps that's more of an example of a game whose appeal is subtle and hard to replicate. It doesn't surprise me at all that it would not be for everyone.

One other thought on making something fun: rather than aiming for the broadest appeal, try to make the game you personally want to play. I think that's what you're already doing.
Nathan Tolbert said…
"try to make the game you personally want to play" -- that's what I did with the original GBA version of Anguna. With this version, it's less "what I want to play" and more about the challenge of trying to make it work on Atari.

Which is part of what is tricky -- I'm not sure who (or if there really IS) a target person for the game itself :)

Either way, thanks for the comments!

Popular posts from this blog

Retrospex 32 Review

RetrospexInternational recently sent me a couple units of their new handheld device, the Retrospex 32, a new dedicated GameboyAdvance emulator handheld.  To make the unit playable out of the box, they pre-loaded a handful of homebrew games, including Anguna, which is why they were kind enough to send me 2 of the units to play with.  I was pretty excited to get my hands on the device and try it (I loved my old GBA micro with a good flash cart!), and see Anguna running on it. So here's my thoughts after playing with it.



Their website lists the Retrospex 32 for £59.99, which is around $100 USD. It seems like it's marketed toward people into retro-gaming (which makes sense for a dedicated GBA emulator device). At that price, with that target market, and such a limited set of functionality (why not make it a multi-machine emulator, and emulate all the old consoles?), it would hopefully do a really good job of it.

The short version of my review: it doesn't. It has one job (emula…

Making the game fun

The real trick for Spacey McRacey (as I'm calling it now) is going to be making it fun.  And that's what I'm rather unsure about at this point.

I have a game design that basically works. The technical issues are mostly sorted out, I just need to get a few more implemented before I can seriously play test it.

But fun? It's hard to know if it's actually going to be any fun to play.  With a 4-player party-style game, it's seems like it might be hard to hit that fine line where everyone is close and competing, where everything feels exciting and tense, as opposed to tedious and boring.  And despite envisioning my game as fun, it might just be boring to play.

Some of that comes down to tweaking it. Tweaking the speeds, difficulties, etc, will make a difference. (If it's too easy to shoot people from behind, then it will be nearly impossible to hold a lead for very long, which could ruin it and make it no fun. If it's too hard to kill the guy in front, it wil…

Killer Queen

So at PRGE, I played an arcade game that just left me amazed.  Killer Queen.

It's a 10-player game. You have 2 cabinets linked together, and 5 players huddled on each one. Each one is a team of 5 people, working together to play a simple one-screen 2d platformer.  But what made it work was the high quality game design.

First, the game is relatively simple, yet there is a lot going on at once.  One player plays the queen, the most important and powerful character on the team. The others start as workers, but can become warriors who can fly around and attack in a very joust-like flappy contest of height.  The real trick is that there are three completely different ways to win: either collect a bunch of berries and bring them back to your base, or ride a REALLY SLOW snail across the screen (while other people try to kill you, and you hope your team protects you), or kill the enemy queen 3 times.  There's some other things going on as well (using berries to upgrade, capturing upgr…